Judicial panel dismisses complaint over alleged misconduct
National News
Audio By Carbonatix
4:00 PM on Friday, November 20
(The Center Square) - The Colorado Commission on Judicial Discipline issued a one-sentence explanation as it dismissed a request for evaluation of all 122 judges who were on the Nov. 3 ballot.
“The request does not allege sufficient grounds for disciplinary or disability proceedings," the panel said.
The Nov. 12 decision was a response to Christopher Gregory, the commission's former chair and executive director, who has made allegations of concealment of judicial misconduct within the state’s judicial branch and its related entities.
Gregory, who's a lawyer, filed his request for evaluation for all 122 judges just one day before the election.
“My RFE alleged that these … judges were all aware of deficiencies in the judicial performance evaluation process but allowed voters to cast their ballots upon fraudulent and legally incomplete information," Gregory told The Center Square.
“My RFE expressly called for the disqualification of the entire Colorado Commission on Judicial Discipline and the entire Colorado Supreme Court, which is constitutionally obligated to form a special tribunal under Article VI, Section 23(3)(f)(II) of the Colorado Constitution," Gregory said. "Instead of disqualifying themselves, as they are obligated to do under the law, the members and staff of the CCJD and the justices are committing the crime of first-degree official misconduct."
The statute of limitations for first-degree official misconduct, which is a class one misdemeanor in Colorado, does not apply to active judges. This means that any violation committed by judges during their active tenure can be penalized so long as they are still on the bench.
The RFE named 122 judges as having allegedly partook in the concealment of judicial misconduct by not publicly raising objections to the performance evaluations of all the judges ahead of the 2026 election.
The RFE also said some judges failed to file personal financial statements required by state law. The Center Square confirmed through TRACER, the state’s online campaign finance filing and public disclosure system managed by the secretary of state’s office, that 25 of the judges listed in the complaint did not file their personal finance statements in 2026 or had inconsistently filed them in the past.
Among those who did not file their statements in 2026 are 1st Judicial District Court Judges Ryan P. Loewer and Andrew Poland and 10th Judicial District Court Judges William Alexander and Allison Ernst, the last of whom has not filed any statements since 2024.
Other judges, including 17th Judicial District Court Judges Sean Finn and Kelly Southerland, filed their statements in 2024 and 2026, but did not file them in 2025. Judge Natalie Stricklin of the 18th Judicial District also failed to file in 2025.
Jack Todd, the secretary of state’s office’s communications director, confirmed with The Center Square that the office is in charge of receiving the judges’ personal finance statements. However, he noted that the office is “not responsible for enforcement in matters of judicial conduct.”
Todd refused to confirm or deny whether the office coordinated with the judicial discipline commission to review the judges' failure to file finance statements.
“That is not the responsibility of this office," Todd said.
Anne Mangiardi, the discipline commission's executive director, provided The Center Square with the commission’s 2024 annual report, which included a discussion about how the commission resolved RFEs in 2023 and years prior relating to the failure to file personal finance statements. However, she made no comment regarding whether the commission evaluated the 2025 or 2026 nondisclosures, whether it pursued formal proceedings or if it coordinated with the secretary of state’s office about the nondisclosures.
“The Judicial Department is unable to comment on any matters that are confidential pursuant to the Colorado Constitution, state statute, and court rules, including any disciplinary complaints resolved prior to public proceedings," said Suzanne Karrer, chief communications officer for the Judicial Department.
"The Commission on Judicial Discipline has sole responsibility for investigating complaints of judicial misconduct and operates entirely independently of the Judicial Department," Karrer told The Center Square.
“The Judicial Department takes its reporting obligations seriously and refers appropriate matters to the commission," she added. "Judges are subject to their own reporting obligations pursuant to the Code of Judicial Conduct.”
Gregory told The Center Square that all of these circumstances are “aggravated by the fact that there is probable cause to suspect that the justices and others have committed the offense of accessory to crime … by intentionally preventing the reporting of admitted sexual harassment and a suspected sexual assault to local law enforcement.
"Chief Justice Monica Marquez, Justice Susan Blanco, Justice Susan Blanco’s husband, Denver District Judge Jon Olafson and others were eyewitnesses/material witnesses to this suspected sexual assault, which occurred in June 2022," Gregory said.
Gregory had also attempted to put on the public record in the Colorado Commission of Judicial Performance's rulemaking hearing on Oct. 26 that some members of the judicial branch knew about another instance of private discipline of Adams County Court Judge Leroy Kirby for having an inappropriate sexual relationship with court staff. He argued that certain members of the state Commission of Judicial Performance had conflicts of interest and should recuse themselves from the rulemaking process.
The rulemaking commission went on to approve the proposed rules following the Oct. 26 public hearing and refused to publish Gregory’s written and oral comments. The commission did not respond to The Center Square's questions about why it did not publish his comments or who made that decision.
Kent Wagner, the executive director of the performance commission, told The Center Square in an email that the panel did not receive information from the secretary of state’s office about the nondisclosures. But he added the panel does “receive information from the Commission on Judicial Discipline that they are able to provide under their rules.”
“Commissions on Judicial Performance base their evaluations on courtroom observation, decision review, case management data, interviews with interested parties, consideration of judge submitted self-evaluation, and an interview with the judge,” Wagner said. He added that the commission does "not have investigative authority beyond the materials and information received as part of the evaluation process.”