Prosecutors try to stop Newsom from lifting death sentences

Carbonatix Pre-Player Loader

Audio By Carbonatix

(The Center Square) - A coalition of 30 county prosecutors, local police agencies and victims’ advocacy groups is asking the California Supreme Court to stop Gov. Gavin Newsom from commuting death sentences for all 548 inmates on death row.


Newsom announced his decision on Nov. 5, writing in an "Open Letter to All Californians" that the state “cannot execute people in our imperfect legal system and remain true to our core values, first among them justice and human decency.”


The Democratic governor, whose office did not respond to The Center Square’s request for an interview, will leave office in January.


Led by the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation and more than half of the state’s district attorneys, the challengers filed a writ of mandate asking the state’s highest court to halt the sweeping clemency effort. They argue Newsom bypassed statutory and constitutional procedures by issuing a blanket reprieve without notifying prosecutors or crime victims in advance or conducting individualized case reviews. They also contend recent administrative rule changes mean life without parole no longer guarantees an inmate will stay behind bars for life.


Foundation CEO Anne Marie Schubert said the legal challenge centers on process and public safety rather than the policy of capital punishment for murder convictions.


“It’s about the process by which he’s trying to undertake a blanket mass commutation without notice to victims or prosecutors without what we call individualized review,” Schubert told The Center Square. “And it’s our position that he has not complied with both statutory and constitutional requirements.”


Schubert pointed to Newsom’s campaign pledges to uphold the will of the people when it comes to keeping the death penalty, as well as the governor's March 2019 moratorium on executions. She argued that Newsom's decision to wait until the end of his term to pursue a mass commutation, without case-by-case review, harms families who have already endured decades of appeals.


“Instead, he chose to do this on the eve of his leaving office without notice to crime victims or prosecutors,” said Schubert, a former Sacramento County district attorney. “And really, it is devastating to these families when you look at these. There is no evidence, I mean, if anybody wants to find somebody that was actually innocent, not somebody that had a case reversed because of, you know, ineffective assistance of counsel or something, but I would challenge anyone to say that we have an actually innocent person.”


Modoc County District Attorney Nina Salarno, a named party in the writ who is also a crime victim, said the pushback against Newsom’s plan is warranted and accused the governor of ignoring the rule of law.


“I think the pushback is absolutely correct,” Salarno told The Center Square. “The governor ignored the rule of law, so the pushback is appropriate and should prevail.”


Salarno criticized Newsom’s open letter to Californians raising concerns about wrongful sentencing, saying it questions a legal system in which a majority of cases have already been affirmed by the California Supreme Court and leaves victims’ families without a voice.


Salarno also argued the dispute carries broader implications beyond California as Newsom eyes a possible run for president in 2028.


“I do think other people will look to it, and absolutely the fact that our governor has made no secret that he is going to try to run for a national level, and if he is going to usurp juries and ignore the rule of law in the state, I think it might be disastrous at the national level,” Salarno said.


California has not carried out an execution since Jan. 17, 2006.


The state dismantled its execution chamber and is spending millions of dollars a year on death row appeals.


While Newsom can unilaterally commute sentences for inmates with a single felony conviction, state law requires approval from at least four of the seven California Supreme Court justices for inmates with prior felony convictions. That applies to most of the 548 prisoners in question. Newsom is holding off on finalizing the commutations pending the court’s ruling.


Schubert and Salarno noted there is no court hearing date set yet, with filings and amicus briefs due by Tuesday. Salarno added that Crime Victims United filed a letter seeking Justice Kelli Evans’ recusal over what the group described as an apparent conflict of interest from prior professional ties to Newsom’s administration.


Human rights groups have praised Newsom's decision as a landmark shift in criminal justice reform. Amnesty International USA Executive Director Nadia Daar called the mass commutation a "decisive and powerful step away from the use of the death penalty."


"Governor Newsom’s decision turns that long pause into meaningful and lasting progress against an inherently cruel, discriminatory and irreversible system," Daar said in a press release.

 

Salem News Channel Today

Sponsored Links

On Air & Up Next

  • The Larry Elder Show
    4:00PM - 7:00PM
     
    Larry Elder personifies the phrase “We’ve Got a Country to Save” The “Sage from   >>
     
  • SEKULOW
    7:00PM - 8:00PM
     
    Jay Sekulow is widely regarded as one of the foremost free speech and religious   >>
     
  • The Mike Gallagher Show
    8:00PM - 11:00PM
     
    Please Welcome Joey Hudson, Who is Guest-Hosting for Mike Gallagher Today! Find   >>
     
  • That Kevin Show
    11:00PM - 1:00AM
     
    Broadcast from the heart of Times Square, Kevin McCullough takes America’s   >>
     
  • That Kevin Show
    12:00AM - 1:00AM
     
    Broadcast from the heart of Times Square, Kevin McCullough takes America’s   >>
     

See the Full Program Guide